Ticking Noise

[eddier1558]

Thought I'd fire up a note on my experience in case there's others out there with the same issue.

First off and to be clear I'm a fussy sod. I had been hearing a ticking noise from my 1.4t GTC for a while. Only audible with the window down and sounded like a nail in a tyre except it was linked to engine speed rather than road speed, could be heard if I rev'd the engine whilst the car was stationary.

Long story short I took the risk of getting the dealer to strip it down to find the issue. They worked with Vauxhall technical who for some reason told them to remove the sump and look at the bearings on the crank. I would have put money on it being the timing chain myself. Auxiliary belt had already been checked. Turns out the big end bearings were all badly scored. Vauxhall have now suggested an exchange engine for the car. I am in a hire Insignia until it's put in at Vauxhalls expense.

Given the input from Vauxhall technical being so accurate first time round I am suspicious that mine may not be the first one of these they have seen. Must also add the dealer has been brilliant throughout the process, definately had the feeling they were working for and with me rather against me which has been good.

Anyway hope that helps someone.



Sent from my D5803 using Tapatalk

[bruce_19]

I think I will be driving mine home with the window down to see if I have the same issue as you since I also have the 1.4T.

What age is your GTC?

[eddier1558]

She's first registered end of December 2013, so almost out of warranty. Told today new engine is at the dealers so tail end of next week she should be ready all things being equal.

Sent from my D5803 using Tapatalk

[bruce_19]

Mine is November 2013 but no ticking noise hopefully it stays away lol

[eddier1558]

Just to finish the thread I finally got the car back today, almost 2 weeks since she went in. She's got an exchange engine (refurbished block and head but rest new as I understand it), new dual mass flywheel and a new clutch all under warranty. Seems grand although sounds a little 'tappety' to me but definitely not ticking anymore. Nice and Shiny!





I am a bit miffed that the engine doesn't get an extended warranty, it expires 20th December when the car hits 3 years old. Seems a bit odd on such a major component replacement. Might try Customer Care, dealer can't do anything about it apparently. Of course also kind of hoping I don't need it....

Sent from my SM-T810 using Tapatalk

[Rusty2009]

Glad you got it sorted.

Sadly Vauxhall won't extend the warranty it's all in the small print.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[eddier1558]

It's always in the small print!!!! Still good to have her back though. Loan Insignia just wasn't the same.

Sent from my SM-T810 using Tapatalk

[stigeye]

It's better to have a new engine without a warranty than an old engine without one.

[eddier1558]

It appears it's not as sorted as I had hoped......

Started her this morning and it sounded very em... dieselly which isn't a great sound for a petrol. Also noticed that the clutch pedal was vibrating in time to my new rattles when I just touched the pedal, went away in gear and almost inaudible in the cabin at idle.

Took her back this evening and she is booked tomorrow for a gearbox, either replacement or rebuild depending on what Vauxhall want the dealer to do with it. Now, disappointment aside, why would a gearbox issue still be audible at idle in neutral?

I have a theory that there may be something up with the new clutch/dual mass combo installed with the replacement engine. Dealer is adamant it isn't but then he would be, he installed it. That said it doesn't really matter as long as it's fixed at no cost to me. So it's back to a Eurocar something for me tomorrow evening.

I kind of hope this is the end of it - can't be that much more to go wrong. This would drive a fella to a Ford...... Apologies for cursing!

Sent from my SM-T810 using Tapatalk

[eddier1558]

To conclude the thread, 4 bearings replaced in the gearbox and all appears to be well. Only covered 100 miles since I got it back but so far so good.

Note to convince Vauxhall that they'd really love to extend that warranty, nothing like a challenge!

Sent from my D5803 using Tapatalk

[eddier1558]

Resurrecting a thread as it's kind of pertinent. I have just offloaded the GTC after the slave cylinder let go on me. With no warranty on the parts and no certainty of goodwill from VX until after I had paid for the work it was just too costly a risk to take. To repair (and add a couple of tyres, brake pads, brake disks that she also needed) was going to be more than to change her and I have lost all faith. I would have been driving along waiting for the next squeak or rattle.

Moved to an insignia elite so I have stuck with Vauxhall as I really like the cars but needed something different. Good spec at the right price, here's hoping it's better built.

I'm sorry to see the wee GTC go and I thank you all for your help over the past year and a half, it's been fun!

New wagon below.

Sent from my SM-T810 using Tapatalk